Comparisons
Comparisons
The argument about which format is better almost always comes down to the question "what for?". The same text is easy to edit in an editable document and easy to read in a PDF; a set of photos is easy to send as an archive and easy to view as separate files. The tables below collect general patterns that help you pick the right option in a minute rather than out of habit.
The right format is the one that leaves the recipient nothing to do except open the file.
How to read the tables: they describe the general properties of formats. A specific program may behave a little differently, especially when it comes to editing and password protection.
PDF vs editable document (DOCX, ODT)
| Criterion | Editable document (DOCX, ODT) | |
|---|---|---|
| Appearance | The same on any device: fonts, margins and pages stay in place | Depends on the program and installed fonts; the layout may shift |
| Editing text | Awkward: the format is designed for reading and printing | Easy: text, tables and formatting are simple to change |
| Working together | Fine for margin comments, but not for shared editing | Convenient: you can make corrections and leave comments |
| When to choose | Contracts, invoices, forms, anything that is read, printed and signed | Drafts, texts under review, templates to fill in |
ZIP archive vs separate files
| Criterion | ZIP archive | Separate files |
|---|---|---|
| Number of attachments | One, however many files are inside | As many as there are files, and one is easy to forget |
| Size | Texts and spreadsheets shrink noticeably, photos and PDFs barely at all | Each file is as big as it is |
| Convenience for the recipient | Must be unpacked before viewing | The needed file can be opened right away |
| Safety | The contents are hidden until unpacked, so archives from strangers call for caution | The type of each file is visible at once from its extension |
Scan as PDF vs scan as image (JPG, PNG)
| Criterion | Scan as PDF | Scan as image (JPG, PNG) |
|---|---|---|
| Multi-page document | All pages in one file and in the right order | Each page in a separate file; the order is easy to mix up |
| Printing | Pages print at the right size without adjustment | Size and margins often have to be set by hand |
| Inserting into another document | The page has to be extracted first | An image is easy to insert into a text or an email |
| When to choose | Official papers, contracts, certificates of several pages | A single page, a receipt, a quick photo for yourself |
How to choose without long deliberation
If the document is to be read or signed, send a PDF. If it is to be corrected, send an editable document. If you are not sure, attach both files under the same name and briefly explain in the email which is for what.
If there are more than three files or they belong together, gather them into an archive. Turn a multi-page scan into a single PDF; a single page can stay an image unless the recipient asked otherwise.
Read next
- Guides
Step-by-step advice: how to identify a format, save a document as PDF, pack files into an archive and name them clearly. The article catalogue is here too.
- Tools
Showing extensions, a PDF viewer, an archiver, a plain text editor, order in folder names and a separate folder for drafts.
- Problems
A file won't open, symbols instead of letters, a PDF can't be edited, an archive asks for a password, an attachment is too big, formatting went wrong.
- Glossary
Extension, format, archive, compression, encoding, macro, metadata and other words about files, in plain language.
- Questions
Answers about the reference, about formats and documents, and about how not to fall for a dangerous attachment.
Sources
- ISO 32000-1 standard (PDF format, 2008)
- Editorial materials of the reference
This page collects general advice about files as the editors understood the topic on the date it was prepared. Programs and devices work differently, and the same menu commands go by different names. If the help for your program says otherwise, trust the help.